Jen Schefft and husband Joe Waterman are first-time parents, welcoming daughter Mae Elizabeth Waterman, PEOPLE confirms.

Mae was born Saturday and weighed in at 7 lbs. and is 20 inches long.

A star of two reality shows, Schefft won Andrew Firestone's heart on The Bachelor in 2003, then went on to star in her own season of The Bachelorette two years later.

She met Waterman, a trader, on a blind date in 2008 and the couple tied the knot in May 2009.